Talk:FamilySearch Indexing: Passenger Lists, Project Updates

Help us improve the indexing and arbitration of this project. Click the Edit This Page button to make suggestions. Messages will be removed after careful review by support and any updates will be posted to the Project Updates page. Many commonly asked questions, such as indexing crossed out information, have already been answered in the Basic indexing instructions.

I have returned the following 2 batches (2 images)  for Image Review.....  of Philadelphia Passenger Lists. See Below:

This Project is Batched Wrong...

As the project is currently set up.. until this project is completed.. over 90% of the passengers will have No ship name and no date of arrival associated with their names...   because most of the passenger pages  do not have the ship name and date of arrival...    She ship name and date of arrival is on the Cover page.. and on the Custom's declaration page (if present)

The National Archives has all images of all ships grouped together by Ship Name and Date of Arrival.. Pages are listed in this order: 1.) Cover page (includes Ship Name &amp; Date of Arrival), 2.)Manifest Header page, with Ship name(with or without passengers... but usually no passengers),  3.) Passenger pages,   4.)  Custom's Declaration page (includes Ship name and usually date.. which is date of arrival)

Therefore,  All  Passengers arrived on a specific date and on a ship with a name....  Unfortunately, the way this project is set up and batched, most passengers will be indexed without a date or ship name.

For Indexing All  Images for Each ship should be grouped together as one batch.. with the Ship name and date of arrival being entered in the Header Data area.. so that each passenger is indexed with a Ship Name and  Date of Arrival.

The Major Error with the Project Setup is: As the project is currently set up.. until this project is completed.. over 90% of the passengers will have No ship name and no date of arrival associated with their names...   because most of the passenger pages  do not have the ship name and date of arrival...    She ship name and date of arrival is on the Cover page.. and on the Custom's declaration page (if present)

Returned this batch: Digital File/Film number 004719556   Batch  98  Same as:  https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.3.1/TH-1-18577-44398-49?cc=1908535&amp;wc=9163960 From: Name of Ship: Maria Elizabeth  Date of Arrival: 3 Oct 1802   33 passengers  As this project is currently batched.. none of the names indexed will have a ship name or date of arrival Digital File/Film number 004719556  Batch 221  Same as: https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.3.1/TH-1-18577-43227-11?cc=1908535&amp;wc=9163960

Returned this batch: Digital File/Film number 004719556  Batch 281  Same as:  https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.3.1/TH-1-18577-42798-37?cc=1908535&amp;wc=9163960 From: Name of Ship: Ship Jacob  Date of arrival:  17 Nov 1802    8 images  158 passengers    As this project is currently batched.. none of the names indexed will have a ship name or date of arrival Begins here: https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.3.1/TH-1-18577-42731-22?cc=1908535&amp;wc=9163960